Judge Roy Bean provided a brand of justice

by Jim Fish

Ozona—In the annals of American history, few figures capture the raw, untamed spirit of the Old West quite like Judge Roy Bean. Born on Aug. 27, 1825, in Kentucky, Bean's life epitomized the essence of frontier justice, where the law was as flexible as the men who enforced it. Known as "The Law West of the Pecos," Bean's legacy is a blend of legend and fact, offering a glimpse into the wild and woolly period of the American expansion westward. 

Roy Bean's path to becoming a legendary figure was anything but ordinary. After a stint in California during the Gold Rush, where he reportedly tried various professions, including saloon keeper, Bean eventually settled just west of the Pecos River in Vinegarroon, Texas, later renamed Langtry in honor of the actress Lillie Langtry, whom Bean admired from afar. Here, he established himself as a justice of the peace, though his authority was more of a self-proclaimed nature than legally appointed in the traditional sense. 

Bean's courtroom was unlike any other; it was set up in his saloon, the Jersey Lilly (a misspelling of Lillie Langtry's name), which doubled as his home, bar, and courthouse. Bean dispensed his unique brand of justice, often with a sense of humor and an individualized touch that was as much about maintaining order as it was about entertaining himself and his patrons. 

Bean's approach to law was pragmatic and often whimsical. When a railroad bridge worker was accidently killed, Judge Bean held an inquest. Searching the body, he discovered a pistol and $48 in cash. Without blinking an eye, he immediately fined the corpse $48 for carrying a concealed weapon and pocketed the money. 

Bean's most celebrated case, illustrating his resourcefulness, concerns a white man charged with killing a Chinese cook employed at a railroad camp. The evidence showed that the American shot the man in cold blood. Things looked bad for the defendant; "I have taken this case out of the hands of the jury," Bean announced, solemnly stroking his long gray beard, "because I believe that I am more competent to handle it. I've gone through this here law book, the revised statutes and there's nothing in it that says it is a crime to kill a Chinaman. The defendant is hereby discharged."  

In another noted case, he renamed Vinegarroon to Langtry after Lillie Langtry's visit, during which he held a special court session in her honor. Ms. Langtry presented the old justice with a photo of herself and so charmed him that he announced, there and then, that the name of the town thereafter would be Langtry. He placed the photo on a shelf beside his out-of-date copy of the Texas revised statutes for many years and was known to use her image as inspiration for his legal decisions. 

Bean's method of justice was not just about the law but about survival and control in a lawless land. He married couples without licenses, granted divorces on the spot, and even sentenced men to work around his property instead of sending them to a distant penitentiary. His court sessions were often recessed for drinks, ensuring his saloon's business thrived alongside his judicial duties. 

Judge Roy Bean's life has been romanticized in numerous cultural outlets. His story inspired movies, books, and even songs, making him a staple in the lore of the American West. His character represents not only the chaotic nature of frontier justice but also the resilience and creativity of individuals in establishing order in the absence of formal institutions. 

Roy Bean died on March 16, 1903, but his legacy as "The Law West of the Pecos" endures. His tale reminds us of a time when America's westward expansion was still in its raw, unpredictable phase, when characters like Bean could emerge from obscurity to leave an indelible mark on history. His methods might not stand up in today's legal world, but they reflect the spirit of adaptation and survival that characterized the American frontier. 

Judge Roy Bean's story is more than just a tale of a man who took the law into his own hands; it's a narrative of how justice was perceived and administered in the Wild West. His life, filled with anecdotes of humor, irony, and rough justice, paints a vivid picture of a bygone era where the line between law and personal whim was often blurred. Bean's legacy, therefore, is not just in the annals of legal history but in the heart of American folklore, embodying the wild, adventurous, and sometimes lawless spirit of the frontier.